Main principles of Ling's physical theory of the
Vladimir V. Matveev
Laboratory of Cell Physiology, Institute of Cytology, Russian Academy of Sciences, Tikhoretsky Ave 4,
St. Petersburg 194064, Russia. E-mail: vladimir.matveev @ gmail.com ;
personal web site: http://vladimirmatveev.ru
Full text [PDF]
Purpose of the theory
The purpose of the theory is to establish the physical nature of the living state. The theory explains the physical mechanisms underlying the key phenomenon of life - the distribution of substances between the cell and its environment and among cell compartments. Understanding of all other features (mechanisms important for cell physiology and cell biology) depends crucially on our understanding of this phenomenon.
Physical mechanisms that the theory uses
The theory describes electronic mechanisms that explain controlled selective adsorption of ions and other substances at proteins and dynamic structuring of water molecules by cell proteins. ATP, the principal cardinal adsorbate for proteins, is the main regulator for both phenomena through induction (changes in electron density of a protein molecule and then of other molecules associated with it). The theory explains observed selective permeability, solute accumulation and exclusion, volume changes in hypo- or hypertonic solutions and cellular electrical potentials in an unifying manner.
Two-state model of cell function
According to the theory, the functioning of the cell or a part of the cell is considered as a reversible transition between two states, the resting state and the state of activity. The resting state is a stable state (but sensitive to perturbations) with a favorable negative free energy. Constant influx of energy and matter is not necessary to maintain this state. The action of an external stimulus or internal signal is to destabilize the resting state and the cell becomes active. The energy is released and is used to perform biological functions. Metabolic processes start in the activated cell, new ATP molecules are synthesized and the cell re-enters the resting state. A cell in the resting state has a favorable negative free energy owing to the adsorption energy of ATP bound by proteins. Activation of the cell starts with the splitting of ATP. The two-state model can be applied to every structure in the cell down to single protein molecules.
Which proteins determine the sorption properties of the cell?
In the resting state, fully extended proteins adsorb the key components (in the physical sense) of the cell: ATP, water and potassium ions. According to the contemporary literature, 30-40% of all cell proteins are natively unfolded proteins. Perhaps these proteins (or some of them) belong to the set of fully extended proteins considered by Ling's theory.
Physical nature of selective adsorption
The following functional groups of proteins have key significance for the theory: the NH- and CO-groups of peptide bonds, and the carboxyl groups of dicarboxylic amino acid residues. The selectivities of peptide groups differ between the two states in respect of: (1) affinity for water molecules, and (2) affinity for the same groups in other peptide bonds in the protein. The selectivity of the carboxylic groups differs in respect of (1) affinity for potassium ions, and (2) affinity for sodium ions or for fixed cationic groups of the protein. The first state of the groups is inherent in the resting state of the cell (or its parts). The second state indicates the active state of the protein. The affinity depends on electron density in the considered functional groups. Low density is characteristic of the resting state, high density of the activated state. The main regulator of the electron density is ATP, which has electron acceptor properties (Ca2+, signal factors, hormones, and chemical modifications of proteins may also assist). In the resting state, ATP is adsorbed by protein and it displaces the electron density in the protein molecule to a site where it is adsorbed. When ATP is split, the electron density in the functional groups increases and their affinity becomes that of the second state.
Adsorption of water
The polypeptide backbone of any fully extended protein exhibits a geometrically regular order of positive (NH) and negative (CO) charges of the dipoles (similar to a one-dimensional crystal grid). This geometry is complementary to a space between the water molecules surrounding the fully extended protein. The complementarity creates conditions for multilayer adsorption of water on the protein surface. As a result, much of the cellular water (the most massive component of the cell, about 44 moles/l) is transformed into an dynamically ordered structure (the entropy of the system is decreased). Because of its interaction with the backbone dipoles, the dipole moment of the adsorbed water is greater than that of free water. Water molecules with larger dipole moments form stronger dipole-dipole interactions (hydrogen bonds are not the only way in which water dipoles interact, but they are the major contributors; if you consider all forces involved in the interaction, it is better to talk about strengthening of the dipole-dipole interactions in general). It is more difficult for molecules of a solute to break the stronger interaction between molecules of adsorbed water, so this water is a poor solvent compared to bulk water. Therefore, solutes are displaced from the volume of adsorbed water into the free water space. Strongly adsorbed water is a barrier to diffusion of large solutes and solutes with incompatible surface structures. The water on the cell surface (rather than lipids) explains the property of cell selective permeability. When you activate a resting cell or some its structure, water is desorbed from the formerly fully extended proteins and the path for diffusion becomes open. The selectivity of each functional group of the polypeptide backbone changes from water to the other functional group of the backbone, and secondary structures of the protein appear (alpha-helix, for example).
Adsorption of potassium ions
Potassium ions accumulate in the resting cell by selective adsorption by the carboxyl groups of dicarboxylic amino acid residues. In the resting state intracellular potassium ions (the most massive ions) are not free. Hence, the observed stable osmotic equilibrium of a cell with an isotonic solution - meaning equal water activity - is mainly a result of the specifically ordered cell water structure. When the cell or part of the cell is activated by removal of ATP from its protein adsorption sites, the carboxyl groups lose their affinity for potassium ions and acquire greater selectivity for sodium ions or to fixed cations of the protein. At the same time, the specifically ordered cell water structure collapses. Potassium ions adsorbed by proteins in the microscopically thin surface layer of a cell produce a resting electrical potential. When the water in the surface layer is desorbed, the water barrier collapses and external sodium ions enter the cell generating a sodium diffusion potential. Sodium ions penetrate into the cell surface and displace potassium ions from the adsorption sites. Potassium ions become free, forming a flow into the environment and generating potassium diffusion potential. These two diffusion potentials shape an action potential.
Structural unit of protoplasm
Protein molecules with bound ATP, water and potassium ions constitute a minimal structure that preserves the basic physical properties of the whole living cell. The vital activity of the cell is reduced to transitions (not a steady-state regime) between the two states:
protein(ATP)m(H2O)n(K+)q <---> protein + mADP + mPi + nH2O + qK+
The key consequences of the theory
The resting potential is the result of the selective adsorption of potassium ions by proteins in the microscopically thin surface layer of the cell.
The action potential is a result of desorption of water from the microscopically thin cell surface protein layer and the appearance of (1) a diffusion electrical potential of sodium ions (influx), and then (2) potassium ions (efflux).
The cell is osmotically stable, in equilibrium with an isotonic solution, owing to the bound state of water (not because intracellular ions are free). In the resting state intracellular potassium ions (the most massive ions) are not free.
The significance of Ling's theory for cell biology
Ling's theory is a revolutionary approach to solving the fundamental problems of cell physiology and biology. It affords us a fresh look at old and modern problems of biology. It is a new methodology of analysis of normal physiological processes and cellular pathology. The distribution of Ling's theory through the scientific community will give scientists an alternative view of the physical mechanisms that are of principal importance for cell physiology, biology and medicine.
See Ling's papers to follow the development of the theory
and its comparison with current views
Ling, G.N. A Physical Theory of the Living State: the Association-Induction Hypothesis. Blaisdell: Waltham, Massachusetts, 1962.
Ling, G.N. In Search of the Physical Basis of Life. Plenum Press: New York, 1984.
Ling GN: A Revolution in the Physiology of the Living Cell. Krieger Publ Co: Malabar FL: 1992.
Ling, G.N. Life at the Cell and Below-Cell Level. The Hidden History of a Fundamental Revolution in Biology. Pacific Press: New York, 2001.
Ling G.N. Physical Theory of the Living Cell. Unnoticed Revolution. Publishing House "Nauka": St.Petersburg, Russia, 2008. (Russian Edition).
is life in terms of the properties and activities of microscopic assemblies of
molecules, atoms, ions and electrons called nano-protoplasm. Cushing Malloy,
Inc., Ann Arbor, Michigan, 2013.
Ling, G. N. Oxidative phosphorylation and mitochondrial physiology: a critical review of chemiosmotic theory, and reinterpretation by the association-induction hypothesis. Physiol. Chem. Phys., 1981, 13, 29-96.
Ling, G. N.
A convergence of experimental and theoretical breakthroughs affirms the pm
theory of dynamically structured cell water on the theory’s 40th birthday.
In Water and the Cell (pp. 1-52). Springer Netherlands, 2006.
Ling, G. N.
History of the membrane (pump) theory of the living cell from Its beginning in
mid-19th century to Its disproof 45 years ago - though still taught worldwide
today as established truth. Physiol. Chem. Med. Med. NMR, 2007, 39, 1-67.
Ling, G. N.
Nano-protoplasm: the ultimate unit of life. Physiol. Chem. Phys. Med. NMR,
2007, 39, 111-234.
Ling, G. N.
A Historically significant study that at once disproves the membrane (pump)
theory and confirms that nano-protoplasm is the ultimate physical basis of life
- yet so simple and low-cost that it could easily be repeated in many high
school biology classrooms worldwide. Physiol. Chem. Phys. Med. NMR, 2008,
Ling's papers in the journal "Physiological Chemistry and Physics and Medical NMR".
Acknowledgments. I thank Gilbert Ling and Paul Agutter for valuable comments on the manuscript.
May 17, 2012
Saint Petersburg, Russia
Full text [PDF]